Stop wasting RFPs: The strategic evaluation checklist to ensure results

An RFP is only as good as the process used to evaluate it. When done well, RFP evaluation drives clarity, alignment, and trust, helping you choose the right-fit supplier not just for today, but for long-term value. In this guide, we’ll walk through how to evaluate RFPs effectively - avoiding common pitfalls and ensuring decisions that support strategic goals, stakeholder buy-in, and supplier relationships.

Let’s strip it back - what’s our objective?

The goal of an RFP evaluation is to select the partner who can deliver the best value to your business, not just the lowest price. A good evaluation process should have the following attribuites:

• Fair and objective - creating a level playing field for suppliers
• Aligned - enabling stakeholders to reach confident decisions
• Customer-focused - grounded in end-user or business needs
• Sustainability-driven - prioritising Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) over headline cost
• Transparent - so suppliers feel respected and trust the outcome
• Auditable - creating a paper trail for internal or external review
• Quantitative - using structured scoring techniques instead of gut feel

A robust eSourcing solution will streamline and enhance all the areas above compared to the same processes being done manually. This includes ensuring messaging and clarifications are handled fairly and correctly, with a searchable audit trail, and an end-to-end decision-making process recorded.

Common RFP evaluation mistakes

RFP evaluations can quickly go off course without a clear framework in place. Here are some of the common misconceptions to avoid:

• “Pricing is scored.” In fact, pricing should be assessed separately - not as part of the qualitative scoring.
• “Procurement makes the final call.” Procurement facilitates, but shouldn’t evaluate - decisions should come from subject matter experts.
• “The panel knows what to do.” Without clear guidance, evaluators may apply inconsistent scoring or miss key criteria.
• “Evaluation ends with scores.” Scoring should lead into discussion and alignment - not replace it.

Modern eSourcing/Source-To-Contract software (S2C) can help streamline this by embedding scoring rubrics, weighting scoring, analysing the data from practically any vantage point and keeping a full audit trail.

What to focus on during evaluation

There are three pillars of a successful evaluation:

1. Clarity - Establish roles, responsibilities, and criteria early. Use the RFP kick-off meeting to align your panel.

2. Objectivity - Avoid bias with a structured, transparent and auditable approach. This ensures confidence from both stakeholders and suppliers.

3. Discussion - Scoring is just the beginning, use the panel session to unpack differences, uncover blind spots, and make smarter decisions.

‍

Today’s leading procurement teams are leveraging AI-powered analytics to bring more speed, consistency, and objectivity to the RFP evaluation process itself. Rather than relying solely on manual scoring, AI can analyse supplier responses and pricing at scale – identifying patterns, flagging inconsistencies, and highlighting standout answers across qualitative and quantitative data. It can also help you analyse a multitude of award scenarios side-by-side within minutes as opposed to hours or days. This helps you as an evaluator to focus on insight rather than admin, reduces human error, and ensures every response is reviewed through the same lens. When embedded into your eSourcing or source-to-contract software, AI-driven evaluation becomes a force multiplier, supporting smarter decisions without adding complexity or resource.

‍

The RFP evaluation checklist

Below, we share this checklist to help structure your evaluation process from start to finish. Click to expand and download.

Summary

RFP evaluation isn’t just about scoring responses - it’s about creating confidence, fairness, and lasting value. With a clear structure and a focus on alignment, procurement can enable smarter, faster decisions that deliver real outcomes.

To go deeper into building an airtight RFP process, you can download the full RFP Playbook - written by Tom Mills – packed with templates, frameworks, and best practices for every stage of the RFP journey.

‍
Start small, scale from there

DeepStream delivers best-of-breed eRFx software with supporting source-to-contract modules, delivering the essential features that empower procurement teams to mature, step by step. We prioritise usability, ensuring our solution is the simplest, cleanest, and most user-friendly in the industry, backed by our dedicated customer success team.

The procurement tech space is filled with hype, overselling, and mis-selling of sweeping, end-to-end digital transformation initiatives. Yet these projects fail because teams are sold overly-complex solutions they’re expected to ‘grow into’. This leads to tech overwhelm, low adoption, and wasted investment.

Our customers start by implementing the least amount of tech needed to achieve their immediate goals, helping them ensure rapid value realisation. Want to benchmark your procurement maturity?

Take our interactive questionnaire to evaluate your tech landscape, identify areas for improvement, and offer tailored recommendations to enhance your procurement processes. Click here to find your tech fit.

Or, have some questions you'd like to chat through with our team? Complete the form below to discuss your business-specific needs.

‍